HD InsightsWhy Language Matters: Reformulating Psychological Distress in Huntington’s Disease

Psychological distress is common among people affected by Huntington’s disease (HD). Both people with premanifest and manifest HD may experience low mood, anxious or repetitive thoughts, increased frustration, lack of motivation, and concern about the future. These challenges can affect relationships, employment, identity, independence and daily life. For people with manifest HD, the emotional and social effects of HD can be just as difficult as the changes in movement, or even more so.

Traditionally, many changes in social and emotional experiences in people with HD have been described using terms such as “non-motor symptoms,” “neuropsychiatric symptoms,” or “psychiatric manifestations.” These terms have helped draw attention to issues beyond motor problems, but they may also imply that distress is simply a direct and unavoidable consequence of changes in the brain. While HD does affect the brain, the experience of distress is also shaped by the individual’s relationships, social circumstances, healthcare experiences, personal histories and uncertainty about the future. Framing distress solely as a consequence of brain changes risks overlooking these other important influences.

“While HD does affect the brain, the experience of distress is also shaped by the individual’s relationships, social circumstances, healthcare experiences, personal histories and uncertainty about the future.”

Why Language Influences Care

The words used to describe distress can shape the care that people receive. If low mood is routinely labelled as “depression” and viewed solely as a symptom of HD, medication may be perceived as the most appropriate response. Likewise, if “irritability” is treated solely as a symptom of HD, professionals may overlook underlying factors such as frustration, grief, fatigue, changes in communication, loss of control, or stress within the family. Similarly, if “apathy” is understood solely as a neurologically mediated loss of motivation, less attention may be given to factors like daily structure, meaningful activities, confidence, embarrassment, and the person’s social environment.

Traditionally, this language has been part of a purely biomedical framework of distress which proposes biomedical explanations for behavioural changes and emotional experiences. While considering such explanations remains important, it should not fully replace potential psychological and social explanations. Instead, effective care requires consideration of how biological, psychological, and social factors interact.

This discussion is particularly significant in HD because it is a hereditary condition and, consequently, many people grow up knowing that it runs in their family. Some individuals witness the decline of a parent or grandparent, while others may experience stigma, secrecy, fear, changes in relationships, or challenging conversations about genetic risk.

As a positive predictive genetic test cannot determine when motor onset will occur, people with premanifest HD may live with uncertainty for years. This may lead them to monitor possible motor or cognitive changes closely and constantly, reconsider their plans for work or family life, and worry about their children or other relatives. Describing these experiences solely as symptoms of HD risks overlooking that they may also be understandable emotional responses to uncertainty surrounding condition onset. This uncertainty profoundly affects people’s lives and those of their families.

Broadening the Biomedical Framework

The biomedical framework used in HD has helped researchers and clinicians identify important changes in movement, thinking, mood, and behavior. Nevertheless, this framework has sometimes contributed to psychological care being overlooked. In particular, research and clinical practice have often relied more heavily on professional descriptions of distress rather than on people’s lived experiences. However, people with HD may have their own complex and meaningful explanations for these experiences and behaviors.

For example, what is labelled as “avoidance” may be a helpful way for someone to manage fatigue or shame, while expressions of anger may be linked to anxious thoughts, frustration, the loss of a valued role, or the experience of feeling misunderstood. Changes in communication may leave a person feeling isolated or unable to express needs or inaccurate assumptions made by others, which can further affect their mental health. If clinicians understand these responses only as symptoms of HD, they may overlook what these experiences mean to the individual.

Language Matters art2

Developing a Shared Understanding Through Psychological Formulation

Psychological formulation provides a useful frame-work for understanding how distress manifests, is conceptualized, and is experienced in people with HD. A formulation is a shared explanation of why a person is distressed, what has influenced that distress, what triggers and maintains it, and what may help to resolve it. While a formulation can include diagnosis and changes in the brain, it also considers the person’s life history, relationships, losses, strengths, values, environment, and concerns about the future.

The HD-specific formulation model below, developed by Dale and colleagues (2022) may be particularly valuable because it considers influences from the past, present, and future in which experiences and expectations can all shape how distress develops and is experienced.

The Past

The past-focused part of the formulation model explores the person’s life story and experiences of HD. It considers who the person was before HD became a major part of their life, including the roles, relationships, values, strengths, and achievements that remain important to them. It also explores their experiences of HD within the family and what they learned about the condition while growing up.

For example, a person may have cared for an affected parent or experienced silence, stigma, fear, or blame. These experiences matter because HD can influence a person’s life long before a diagnosis is made. For some people, witnessing the decline of a parent becomes almost like a “window to the future,” leading them to imagine a similar future for themselves.

For others, growing up with an affected parent may involve adverse childhood events (ACEs) such as emotional abuse or neglect. Although ACEs are often discussed in relation to post-traumatic distress, research in the general population shows that ACEs are associated with a wide range of mental health outcomes in adulthood, including psychosis, substance misuse, and self-harm.

The Present

The present-focused part of the formulation model explores how distress is experienced right now. This may include low mood, anxious thoughts, frustration, anger, repeated questioning, social withdrawal, loss of motivation, or thoughts of suicide. It also considers physical changes, thinking skills, communication, pain, sleep, hunger, medication effects, relationships, activity levels, and how a person interacts with their environment.

For example, an episode of anger may be related to difficulty adapting to change, pain, noise, feeling rushed, changes in communication, loss of independence, or fear. A psychological formulation helps clinicians understand the factors that may be contributing to a person’s behavior and respond to the person’s underlying needs, rather than focusing solely on managing “symptoms.”

The Future

The future is also a central concern in people with HD, who may fear losing their independence and becoming like their parent with HD. This often involves concerns about requiring full-time care, facing a reduced life expectancy, or passing the condition on to their children. These concerns can profoundly shape how people experience distress in the present.

A person who avoids appointments may not simply be “in denial”—they may be trying to keep frightening thoughts about the future at a distance. Someone who becomes distressed around people with later-stage HD may be responding to previous experiences or to fears of what may lie ahead. When future planning is approached from this perspective, it can support a person’s sense of choice, control, and hope, rather than dismissing it.

Reformulating Psychological Distress

The broader framework offered by psychological formulation changes how common experiences of psychological distress associated with HD are understood. Irritability is often described as a “core psychiatric feature” of HD, but it likely involves more than the biological effects of the condition. It can also be shaped by low mood, anxious thoughts, changes in communication, reduced perceptions of control, fatigue, embarrassment, or feeling criticized.

Decreased motivation may partly reflect neurological change but can also be influenced by a lack of daily structure, limited opportunities for meaningful activities, reduced confidence, or expectations to participate in activities that no longer match the person’s abilities. Perseveration, often described as the repetition of an action, question, or idea, may appear obsessive. However, it can also reflect changes in planning and flexible thinking, anxiety, or a strong need for predictability.

Low mood is common in people with HD and risk of suicide is a serious concern. Low mood may be difficult to recognize because some of its features overlap with changes in sleep, slowed movement, fatigue, and reduced motivation. Anxious thoughts and worries may also be related to concerns about genetic discrimination, financial pressures, the impact of HD on family members, future disability, and uncertainty about the future.

These experiences are not necessarily direct consequences of HD, as they may also reflect meaningful responses to the challenges of living with the condition. Describing them only as “non-motor symptoms,” “psychiatric features,” or “neuropsychiatric manifestations” of HD can make them appear inevitable, even though many of the factors contributing to distress may be addressed through appropriate support.

The Role of Psychological Therapy

Psychologically informed understanding and support should be recognized as integral components of care for people with HD. Psychological therapy should also be available when appropriate. Although the evidence base for psychological therapies in people with HD remains limited (Zarotti et al., 2020), early studies suggest that a range of approaches may be beneficial for some people (Dale et al., 2025; Eccles et al., 2021). Different therapies are suited to different needs and preferences, so decisions should be made collaboratively to ensure that the chosen approach is appropriate for the individual.

As HD affects movement, thinking, communication, swallowing, mood, behavior, family life, and participation in the community, no single profession can fully address every aspect of this condition. Effective care therefore requires collaboration between psychology, psychiatry, neurology, nursing, speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, physiotherapy, dietetics, social care, families, and, most importantly, the person with HD.

A formulation-based approach can help a multidisciplinary team develop a shared understanding, coordinate consistent responses, identify unmet needs, and ultimately provide more person-centered care.

Conclusion: Keeping People with HD at the Center

Language is not a matter of style or semantics. Referring to the psychological distress experienced by a person with HD as a “symptom” may be a convenient shorthand, but it can narrow the questions that clinicians ask. What is painful, frightening, frustrating, or unsupported in this person’s life? What has HD meant within their family? What do they fear? What remains important to them? What helps them feel more in control?

Distress in HD is real, but we can find ways to support people in managing it. Changes in the brain are an important part of the picture, but they do not provide the whole explanation. Medication is appropriate for some people, but care should also include psychological understanding, social support, and practical adaptations. Moving from thinking only in terms of “symptoms” to understanding distress in a broader context creates more space for hope, choice, and compassionate care. It encourages professionals to remain curious and, most importantly, helps keep the person with HD at the center of their care. •

 “Describing these experiences solely as symptoms of HD risks overlooking that they may also be understandable emotional responses to uncertainty surrounding condition onset.”

References

Dale M., Wood, A., Zarotti, N., Eccles, F., Gunn, S., Kiani, R., Mobley, A., Robertson, N., & Simpson, J. (2022). Using a Clinical Formulation to Understand Psychological Distress in People Affected by Huntington’s Disease: A Descriptive, Evidence-Based Model. Journal of Personalized Medicine, 12(8), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.3390/jpm12081222

Dale, M., Melvin, K., Eccles, F. J. R., Bell-Jones, L., Khan, Z., Wells, R., Johnson, J., Zarotti, N., & Simpson, J. (2025). Experience and acceptability of a guided self-help intervention for anxiety for individuals with Huntington’s disease (GUIDE-HD trial): A qualitative study. Neuropsychological Rehabilitation, 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1080/09602011.2025.2600422

Eccles, F. J. R., Craufurd, D., Smith, A., Davies, R., Glenny, K., Homberger, M., Rose, L., Theed, R., Peeren, S., Rogers, D., Skitt, Z., Zarotti, N., & Simpson, J. (2021). Experiences of Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy for Premanifest Huntington’s Disease. Journal of Huntington’s Disease, 10(2), 277–291. https://doi.org/10.3233/JHD-210471

Zarotti, N., Dale, M., Eccles, F., & Simpson, J. (2020). Psychological Interventions for People with Huntington’s Disease: A Call to Arms. Journal of Huntington’s Disease, 9(3), 231–243. https://doi.org/10.3233/JHD-200418